I love my Super and I load them hot for open class and even hotter for defense. Super is too rare these days, and 10 mm is too much caliber for the majority of people to handle efficiently. I agree with you but I understand that there just has not been enough shootings where. If you are in a position where you can use a shotgun or rifle for home defense then that is always going to be more effective. It’s more important to actually train, and shoot your pistol than it is to have a 5% higher chance of achieving a one shot stop. Lastly, it’s plainly obvious that any reasonable self defense caliber, between. But it would be interesting to see what the difference is. I don’t believe it would make a double digit difference as hollow points really only create a slightly larger wound channel, they aren’t magic. I think there is likely to be some difference if we had data on shootings with hollow points. Next, we need to keep in mind that many of these shootings were using ball ammo. This is why many military and tactical units train failure to stop drills where you make center of mass hits, and then transition to the pelvic girdle or head. So much of our training stops at putting a round or rounds on target, we never consider what to do when an aggressor continues their violent actions. I think Greg did a great job of compiling a lot of great information, and it tends to indicate a few key points.įirst, I think it’s incredibly important to highlight the fact that there is roughly a 10-15% chance that an assailant will not stop their attack even while taking effective fire. We need to be careful when we start to draw concrete conclusions from this data. Practically speaking this may not even be statistically significant if we controlled the amount of rounds shot in an engagement. The important take away from this chart is that there is less than a 10% spread between 38 special and 45 ACP. It is just slower to shoot a big, heavy recoiling revolver than it would be to shoot an AR15, or a 9mm semi auto. This explains why the 44 magnum has a higher one shot stop percentage than the long guns. Handgun calibers that are used in revolvers are more likely to have higher one shot stops because you cannot fire them as quickly as semi automatic firearms. However, we need to be careful here as we have one large confounding variable. You can see that generally as the size of the round decreases the probability of a one shot stop decreases as well. We’ll look at a few other metrics on one stop shootings a little later on as well. We should also be aware that this metric is derived by taking the number of incapacitations and dividing it by the number of rounds a person took. Things like accidental shootings or suicides were not counted. It should be noted that this data comes from police and military engagements. If they were running they must have dropped to the ground within 5 feet. Greg defined this as an assailant immediately ceasing to shoot or fight after a shot. If we examine this chart we see that shotguns and all center fire rifles have a much higher likelihood of stopping a subject with only one round fired.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |